Up in the Air Dance Remix is Unsatisfying

Normally, I look forward to screener season. Woohoo—free movies! At least once a year, for a few weeks, my SAG dues seem to deliver a tangible benefit.

Last night was my first viewing of any of the four screeners I have (thus far) received, and it was not an auspicious beginning. Up in the Air looks like it might be a pretty enjoyable movie. Might be, that is–I couldn’t say for sure, because the DVD I got is either a faulty reproduction or some kind of Special Jigsaw Puzzle/MadLibs/stoned Director’s Cut edition.

Minor plot spoilers hereunder
But if you read it anyway, you’ll know how I felt.

Up-in-the-air_collageMy DVD’s rendering began with a phone call scene between the George Clooney and Vera Farmiga characters, in which she reprimands him for having transgressed the boundaries of what apparently had been their rather casual relationship. Cut to George in the office of his boss Jason Bateman, who lets him know that someone named Natalie has quit. Cut to George receiving his 10-million-miler status card during a flight, complete with congratulatory announcement from the flight attendant and a special sit-down visit from the pilot (Sam Elliott). Cut to aforementioned Natalie character (Anna Kendrick) taking a picture of George holding a cardboard cutout of his sister and soon-to-be-brother-in-law in front of the St. Louis Airport terminal.

“Wow,” I thought, “they’re really going all-out with this whole non-linear narrative thing. But why are the edits so abrupt? Like, with some of them coming in mid-sentence?”

Soon enough, even my slow uptake had sussed out the situation. If nothing else, I knew things were fucked up when the end credits started rolling at the 50 minute mark. Two-thirds of the way through the movie I made it to the opening titles sequence. Following that, I came across a couple of scenes I’d already seen earlier; I kept watching them just to see if they added any layers of meaning the second time through. I was half hoping they’d pull some kind of Groundhog Day thing where the scene would take a left turn and end up somewhere different than it had the previous time, but no such luck.

And then, all of a sudden, it was over. I think. The last thing I saw was Kendrick giving an auto industry middle manager the axe via Skype, and the guy yelling, “What the fuck is this?!?” Not an entirely inappropriate button for the end of my viewing experience. For a second I thought the screener was going to tell me that all the answers I needed about my future SAG Awards voting options would be found in the glossy packet it was printing out for me. If it had done that, I might have had to vote for the movie in every category out of admiration for its ballsy marketing-fu. Missed opportunity, Paramount.

Now I’m left to contemplate whether to cast votes for Clooney (Best Actor), Farmiga or Kendrick (both nominated for Best Supporting Actress). Part of me wants to ignore them all as retribution for Paramount’s not bothering to send me a proper screener. This would of course be an entirely wasted gesture of principle, since I seriously doubt that the studio would ever find out I had done so, or even if it did, would give a shit. There’s also no sense in punishing my three fellow thespians for the situation, since I’m quite sure that awards-screener quality control was not among their contractual responsibilities (if it was, they need to fire their agents).

I guess I’ll have to re-assess after I’ve seen the other performances. I can only hope that none of my other screeners were recorded on “shuffle.”

Tags: , , , , , ,

  1. Donaco!’s avatar

    I’m off to check out my DVD!

    (Since I saw the movie in a theatre, I just stuck the DVD on a shelf.)

    Reply

  2. Donaco!’s avatar

    It plays fine in Donacoland….

    Reply

    1. Derek’s avatar

      This proves what I had previously suspected: Paramount meant it as a personal slight. What the hell they think I did to them is anyone’s guess.

      Reply

  3. Josh’s avatar

    What a horrendous review… As a fellow film critic who gets many, many more than four screeners at awards season, it’s just plain annoying to hear you proclaim your greatness… Just review the movie, or shut up about it.

    And my screener copy played just fine, as did the print when I saw it at a screening.

    Reply

    1. Derek’s avatar

      Woohoo! FINALLY. This blog has been suffering from a serious shortage of comment-thread smack from random haters. Josh, where have you been all my life?

      Look, call my post “horrendous” all you want — just don’t call it a review. It’s not a review, it’s a cheeky blog post about me slowly realizing that I had a faulty screener of Up in the Air and feeling gypped about it.

      Also, to be clear: I’m not a movie critic. I’m a blogger. (I’m also a SAG member, which I mentioned at the beginning of the post in order to indicate why I receive any screeners at all.) True, I have posted a few movie reviews before, but I don’t think two or three reviews out of nearly 150 posts on this blog makes me a Film Critic.

      As for your entreaty that I “just review the movie, or shut up about it,” I have a question: how the hell could I have written a review of Up in the Air? I haven’t seen it! As for shutting up about it… come on now. It’s my blog, and I’ll post on it whatever I feel like posting. If you don’t like that, please remember that you are welcome to post comments telling me how much I suck.

      Reply

  4. Josh’s avatar

    Here’s where I would usually politely apologize, and call it a day, but since you seem to enjoy my being an asshole, here I go:

    I only called it a review because I remember seeing you associate a rating with it.Re-reading this post, it wasn’t here, but I’m almost positive you put a rating to it either on IMDb or wherever it was I read this post. If that was the case, I don’t see how you could do that. But maybe I was mistaken and didn’t actually see a rating… Who knows.
    But if I may offer a suggestion- go check it out and DO watch it. Then review it (or make a post about it). You’re missing out.

    Reply

    1. Derek’s avatar

      Funny, but you’re sounding suspiciously like a nice guy. Not that there’s anything wrong with that. ;-) It’s not that I want commenters to be assholes, I’m just a big proponent of lively debate. I’ve also heard that controversy drives blog traffic. Maybe I need to be more provocative… heh, story of my life.

      I don’t recall assigning a rating to Up in the Air anywhere… but like you say, who knows. Somebody could even have stolen my content, stuck a rating on the end of it and called it their own.

      I fully intend to take your suggestion and watch the movie in its intended form. From what I could tell, I think I’ll like it.

      Reply